Since I have started using learning maps, I’ve been continuously looking for better mindmapping tools based on simple rules I considered a requirement for upgrading my current utility. Efficient, or faster and easier, ways in creating the map, moving around and getting information from the map, and over all look, or
- faster data input,
- easy to layout/arrangement data,
- easier to read or search the map, and
- adding additional data formats other than text, like audio, pictures, video, etc
My first, Freemind, is great in getting your thoughts since you can have your hands stick on the keyboard and add master/parents /child and so on to the map. Its faster. No need to move from mouse to keyboard at any time. However its limited to its layout as it can only follow the original theme and you cannot arrange the branches without affecting the others. Viewing the map is also fast, moving, panning and zooming is also easy. Searching however cannot look at the nodes above it so you need to go first to main node to search the whole map. Cannot add pictures on it but you can use built in tags or little icons and can use Clouds to group nodes together. The whole map would be made up of lines, words, colors and icons.
When I got my Mac, I used Mindnode and it does have the same ease the freemind provides in placing data on the map plus you can import and export files to freemind. Also it allows you to rearrange your branches without restrictions that Freemind does. And it allows you to move/pan/zoom by simple mouse keyboard combinations. Pictures are not possible though, so you still end up with a map with lines and colors and text on it.

Now I saw Xmind and it looks like adding data has almost the same ease compared to that of the first two applications PLUS now it does allow to add pictures on it. A lot more themes can be used unlike the first two. However moving/panning around, working with the whole map, finding where you are and deciding what the whole map is all about needs a little getting use to. You don’t have the “Space bar then press the left mouse button then drag” panning style that the Mindnode has. You use the mouse scroll wheel to move and zoom, which is too slow for me and a problem for those without the wheel. Then the branch width default isn’t multiline unlike the Mindnode where in all branches have a specified width so sentences with more words than the width gets automatically written on the next line. This makes the Xmind map flow horizontally more even if the branches are spread around the main node. This can be changed though but would need users to change it first. Also like freemind, xmind wont allow you to rearrange the nodes without rearranging the nodes closed to it. This wont allow you to maximize the use of the total area of the page. Without the ability to add pictures, this new application wouldn’t replace mindnode from my arsenal.

This is just a personal opinion since some of my friends have different ways and needs in making and using a mind map.